By Michael GallagherShareNewsweek is a Trust Project memberThe Minnesota Vikings were such big believers in second-year quarterback J.J. McCarthy that they let 4,000-yard, 35-touchdown quarterback Sam Darnold walk in free agency back in March so they could hand the keys to the offense over to the QB they traded up to get in the 2024 draft.
But so far, the return on investment in McCarthy has been disappointing, to say the least.
In six games, McCarthy has thrown for fewer yards (1,216 to 929) with more interceptions (10 to 5), and a significantly lower completion percentage (65.1 to 54.1) than backup Carons Wentz did in five games.
McCarthy has also thrown an interception in six straight games (the longest streak in the NFL), and Minesota is averaging just 247.5 yards per game when he starts — the second-worst number in the league ahead of the 1-10 Tennessee Titans — leading The Athletic’s Dianna Russini to ask what everyone is thinking.
“I think the question that we got to start asking — and this is going to get a headline — is J.J. McCarthy going to be a Minnesota Viking quarterback next season?” Russini questioned on the “Hoge and Jahns” podcast last week.
More News: Jason Kelce Sends Clear Message on Eagles’ Jalen Hurts-AJ Brown Drama
...More News: High-Profile Head Coach Turned Down Penn State Job: Report
And now, it seems the Vikings themselves may have buyer’s remorse when it comes to McCarthy.
Several recent reports indicate that discussions have been held about bringing in an experienced veteran next season to start and give McCarthy another year to sit, learn the offense, and develop while not under duress every week.
But as Russini pointed out on Wednesday, there’s starting to be more questions than answers when it comes to McCarthy’s future in Minnesota.
“I’ve been told there were some concerns about how another year sitting on the bench would affect [McCarthy],” Russini wrote. “And would it even help? Every question has a cousin, and suddenly they’re multiplying. Can a raw but talented quarterback grow fast enough to match a team built to win yesterday?
“… Right now, the question ringing through the building and across the league is impossible to ignore: “Why did you ever let Sam Darnold go?”
The unfortunate reality is the Vikings are built to win now, and they don’t have the luxury of time to wait for McCarthy to figure it out.
If another quarterback is brought in, it’s possible it could spell the end of McCarthy’s Vikings tenure after just two years.
More News: Deion Sanders Announces Controversial Move Before Colorado Season Finale
Request Reprint & LicensingSubmit CorrectionView Editorial & AI Guidelines
Add Newsweek as a preferred source on Google to see more of our trusted coverage when you search.Recommended For You
NFLCBS Makes Big Ratings Announcement Ahead of Chiefs-Cowboys Game2 min read
NFLNFL Thanksgiving Games 2025: Full Schedule and What to Know6 min read
NFLBrowns QB Shedeur Sanders Gets Bad News With Latest Prediction3 min read
NFLJason Kelce Speaks Out on Eagles’ O-Line Struggles Following Cowboys Loss2 min read
NFLEagles DC Announces Roster Shake-Up After Injury to Key Starter2 min read
NFLShedeur Sanders’ Long-Term Future With Browns in Question2 min readRelated Podcasts
Top Stories
PoliticsHow China’s Growing Nuclear Strength Is Keeping Russia in Check11 min read
WorldTrump Sending Witkoff to Moscow, End of Russia-Ukraine War in Reach—Live3 min read
Live BlogThanksgiving Winter Storm Live Tracker, Updates as Heavy Snow to Hit1 min read
NewsDonald Trump Responds to Kash Patel Firing Rumors4 min read
NewsDemocrats’ Chances of Flipping Republican Seat in Tennessee Get Huge Boost3 min read
U.S.Kristi Noem Among Those Named in Judge’s Criminal Inquiry: Full List2 min readTrending
MoneyNew ‘Cash Law’ Could Change Grocery Store Rules3 min read
SnowfallWinter Storm Warning Issued As 25 Inches of Snow To Strike5 min read
U.S. Economy‘Mass Blackout’ Starts Today: What to Know3 min read
Home PricesPrice Correction ‘Worse Than 2008’ Coming To US Housing Market—Analyst5 min read
ArkansasRepublican Switches Party To Democrats Amid Concerns About Affordability3 min readOpinion
OpinionThanksgiving in America | Opinion5 min read
OpinionWhen Strength Becomes a Burden—Reimagining the Strong Black Woman | Opinion4 min read
OpinionConventional Wisdom: Trump Turkey Pardoning Edition3 min read
OpinionDoes the US Need a Third Political Party? Newsweek Contributors Debate5 min read
OpinionGOP Rep.: The U.S. Must Close Critical AI Chip Export Loophole Exploited by China | Opinion5 min read
