New York Giants NewsJames HickeyTue, November 25, 2025 at 11:00 AM UTC·9 min readGood morning, New York Giants fans!
From Big of Blue View
Giants fire defensive coordinator Shane Bowen after yet another loss
Giants head coach Mike Kafka says it was ‘right time’ to move on from Shane Bowen
‘Things I think’: The Giants could be having a fun year — instead, they have made a mess
‘Kudos and Wet Willies’: Mike Kafka, offense impress while Giants defense loses again
Dexter Lawrence was in tears on sideline for NY Giants OT loss to Giants
Mike Kafka says fourth-down decision to try for TD ‘was a correct one’
NY Giants release placekicker who missed 3 extra points in 2 weeks
PFF grades and snap counts for the Giants’ loss to the Lions
Malik Nabers tweets, deletes, criticism of Mike Kafka’s decisions in Giants vs. Lions
Even President Trump has an opinion about latest loss by NY Giants
What did we learn from the Giants’ 34-27 loss to the Lions?
New York Giants head coaching search: Everything you need to know
Other Giant observations
What you need to know about Giants interim defensive coordinator Charlie Bullen | New York Daily NewsCarl Banks unloads (NSFW) on the defensive unit‘Painful disbelief’ in Detroit as Giants give another victory away | The Record“Charlie Bullen has been a great asset to me and the rest of the guys in the room, and continuing to kind of grow,” Thibodeaux said in August. “Not just my ability on the field, but know what weight I want to play at, know what size, know what side of the ball I like and just figuring out what works for me and kind of just honing in on it, using that as my strength.”
Thibodeaux added that Bullen helped him more with his mindset than with any particular technique. “I think it’s the consistency of greatness,” he said. “It’s understanding that, ‘Yeah, you know it, but let’s just go over it three more times.’ I think it’s that 10,000-hour mindset.”
AdvertisementAdvertisementAdvertisementGiants, Joe Schoen vote off another coach as 2025 season devolves into ‘Survivor’ | The AthleticThe disbelief for the New York Giants isn’t about the how. It’s the why.
Because in reality, the players and coaches know the reason the losing keeps happening, and in heartbreaking fashion. They see the film and the crease Jahmyr Gibbs blazed through on the first play of overtime, with Dexter Lawrence on the sideline after getting nicked in the first quarter. He gutted through whatever he was dealing with for much of the game, and the Giants were hopeful of saving him early in OT for bigger plays to come.
NFL Week 12: Biggest questions, takeaways for every game | ESPN.comThe 2-10 New York Giants have turned the final weeks of this woeful season into the NFL version of “Survivor,” voting someone off the coaching staff after each loss. On Monday, defensive coordinator Shane Bowen’s torch was extinguished after his unit blew another double-digit fourth-quarter lead in a 34-27 overtime loss to the Lions. That came two weeks after head coach Brian Daboll was voted off the island after the Giants dropped to 2-8 for the third consecutive season.
The coaching staff had been Schoen’s “Immunity Idol.” Now, he’s out of fall guys. The focus for the final five games shifts exclusively to the roster Schoen assembled that hasn’t been able to make a play to secure a win in the three games they’ve led by at least 10 points in the fourth quarter.
Why do the Giants keep losing in such excruciating fashion? The Giants just can’t finish. This was their fifth loss this season in a game in which they had a double-digit lead. All were on the road, and that ties an NFL record. They couldn’t get in the end zone despite reaching the 2-yard line on a seven-minute drive late in the fourth quarter. Then, they couldn’t stop the Lions from kicking the tying field goal with less than a minute to play or take down Gibbs on his overtime touchdown run. It doesn’t matter whether it’s Mike Kafka or Brian Daboll as head coach. The Giants’ inability to make big plays in the clutch and close out games remains a problem.
Darius Alexander has improved as the season has progressedGiants’ Jermaine Eluemunor claims victory over Aidan Hutchinson | USAToday.comGiants RT Jermaine Eluemunor gave up the sack to Lions DE Aidan Hutchinson on the final play of the game. It was the only sack the Giants allowed all day. Eluemunor to me on his matchup with Hutchinson:
AdvertisementAdvertisementAdvertisementThe Giants can compete with anyone, but winning has been a different story | New York Post“How do I say this respectfully: He did not do a damn thing all (expletive) game. He strikes me as the type of guy that would try to celebrate that one play, but for most of the day I was on an island with him and he didn’t do anything. Obviously I’m (expletive) about the last play, but at the same time, there’s not much you can do. They know what you’re going to do and he still tries to give me his best move and I run him by the quarterback and he just manages to run back upfield and get the sack.”
The Giants were on a roll early in the fourth quarter.
They pulled off an epic trick play, during which Gunner Olszewski threw a pass to quarterback Jameis Winston, who broke a tackle from Lions linebacker Derrick Barnes to power his way into the end zone for a 33-yard touchdown. The Giants were sitting pretty — up by 10 with a little more than 12 minutes left in the fourth.
Jameis Winston nominated for FedEx Air & Ground Player of the Week | Giants.comQuarterback Jameis Winston has been nominated for the FedEx Air & Ground Player of the Week Award. During the Giants’ Week 12 overtime loss in Detroit, Winston completed 18 of 36 passes for 366 yards, two touchdowns and one interception for a 93.1 passer rating. He added four rush attempts for 13 yards and also caught a 33-yard touchdown pass from wide receiver Gunner Olszewski on a trick play. It was the first reception of the veteran quarterback’s career. Winston became just the second player since 1960 to throw for 350+ yards, two or more touchdowns and catch a touchdown in a game, joining Matt Ryan (2018).
AdvertisementAdvertisementAdvertisementBaldy gives praise to Giants offenseThree big NFL Week 12 comeback wins: Cowboys, Lions, Chiefs | ESPN.comGiants’ Mike Kafka shows shades of Bill Walsh (or at least Dan Campbell) on trick plays | The AthleticThe Giants chose to go for it on fourth-and-goal from the 6-yard line. It’s a curious move for commentators who are sure that six is more than three, but history suggests that teams down three are far less incentivized to try to score a touchdown to win the game in regulation than those same teams down six. Throw in the chances of winning the game with a conversion, killing significant clock by drawing a penalty and the added field position benefit of starting the Lions inside their own 10-yard line with a miss, and ESPN’s model greatly preferred going for it on fourth-and-goal.
The early strike also recalled the trick-play psychology Bill Walsh (Pro Football Hall of Fame class of 1993) and Paul Brown (class of 1967) espoused.
“One of the interesting things about Paul Brown football is that he would always be terribly upset if someone would run a reverse before we did, or a run-pass before we did,” Walsh wrote in the 1980s. “He would grab the phone and scream in my ear, ‘They did it before we did!’ This was very distressing because it sounded so dated.”
This week’s opponent
NFL Week 12: Biggest questions, takeaways for every game | ESPN.comHow will the Patriots recover from being decimated by injuries, especially on the offensive line? Left guard Jared Wilson (ankle) was carted to the locker room in the first quarter, and left tackle Will Campbell (knee) was carted off in the third quarter. That wiped out quarterback Drake Maye’s entire blindside before the final quarter. Good health had been a key factor for the Patriots entering Week 12, as they started the same offensive line in 10 of 11 games. Four-year veterans Ben Brown (guard) and Vederian Lowe (tackle) were the in-game replacements; rookie Marcus Bryant (seventh round) is another option at tackle. Arguably nothing is more important for the Patriots than protecting Maye’s blindside, and that task just became harder.
AdvertisementAdvertisementAdvertisement10 lessons learned from Patriots vs. Bengals in NFL Week 12 | Pats PulpitDrake Maye overcomes his early struggles: The Patriots’ quarterback started the game just about as bad as you possibly could on Sunday. He was missing players, and threw a downright terrible pick-six. It was no surprise that the Patriots were struggling, but Maye ended up turning things around. His throw down the middle to DeMario Douglas on third down was a thing of beauty; to throw with that kind of anticipation that far down the field is special, there’s no other way to say it. His connection with Hunter Henry is obvious as well, and he was able to get him the ball consistently on Sunday. He didn’t target Stefon Diggs much, but still hit him in a huge moment on the final offensive drive to pick up a big third down. Maye finished just a few yards short of his first 300-yard passing game, and, even though he had some struggles early, it was encouraging to see him bounce back and play well after the first quarter.
Around the league
Joe Burrow is expected to return as Bengals’ starting QB vs. Ravens | The Athletic
Tee Higgins to miss Thanksgiving game against Ravens after suffering concussion in Week 12 | CBSSports.com
Vikings QB J.J. McCarthy in concussion protocol following loss to Packers | NFL.com
C.J. Stroud remains in concussion protocol, will start once cleared | Pro Football Talk
Dillon Gabriel cleared but Shedeur Sanders to start vs. 49ers | ESPN.com
Chip Kelly, NFL’s highest-paid OC, fired by Raiders after just 11 games | SB Nation
AdvertisementAdvertisementAdvertisementBBV mailbag
Have a Giants-related question? E-mail it to [email protected] and it might be featured in our weekly mailbag.
BBV YouTube
You can find and subscribe to Big Blue View YouTube from the show’s home page
BBV on X: Follow @BigBlueView | Ed Valentine: @Valentine_Ed | Threads: @ed.valentine | Bluesky: @edvalentine
BBV on Facebook: Click here to like the Big Blue View Facebook page
BBV on YouTube: Subscribe to the Big Blue View YouTube channelBBV on Instagram:Click here to follow our Instagram page
AdvertisementAdvertisement